Message Forums
Home > Community > Mixing Forum > Output and Mixdown Discrepancy - Mixing Forum

Mixing Message Forum

Output and Mixdown Discrepancy
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 22, 2006 09:22 pm

I am using Cakewalk Homestudio 2XL and as an example, I currently have a song recorded with 5 tracks that plays in the program and through the monitors at a very loud volume while retaining perfect clarity. Now why is it that when I export, its not nearly so loud and it requires a troublesome mastering process just to get it back to how great sounding it was in the program originally?
colonel_sanders
edit0r

Member
Since: Aug 17, 2004
Mar 23, 2006 06:05 am

Try exporting to another format like aiff. Worked for me :S lol
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 23, 2006 02:38 pm

Sounds easy, but can aiff work in media players or burn to cd's which can play on normal cd players?
peterparker
The Beat Keeper

Member
Since: Dec 16, 2004
Mar 23, 2006 08:57 pm

yeah, it works perfectly fine.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 23, 2006 10:36 pm

Well the version of cakewalk I am using that I stated above, only exports in .wav .wma and .mp3 unless there is some other way to export as well...
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Mar 26, 2006 07:44 pm

When you go to export to wav are you making sure you have all the boxes checked? So it will export with all your FX settings and volume settings as well.

You may also want to bump up your master faders in Sonar when you export. Not a whole lot, but try a little bit at a time. Then you will know about where you need to be with a mix of that sort.

I dont know what is troublesome about shooting a 2 track mix into a wave editor to pump up the volume. It only takes me a matter of about 60 seconds to open Wavelab and import the 2 track mix and then another minute to maximize it.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 26, 2006 09:34 pm

Noize, all boxes are checked by default and remain that way upon export. I do not own sonar. Also, boosting the level in a wave editor never compares to the original high level of the mix in cakewalk homestudio before export. You could go into further detail about compression and mastering, but why? Why do I have to do all of this when my mix is so loud and clear in the software? Why does it have to export as crap for me to fix?

I just dont understand, maybe because its all under the specialized file extension when in cakewalk and then .wav is a step down from that. Thats all I can think of...
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Mar 26, 2006 10:56 pm

Oh ya, forgot. Home Studio 2 XL. Either way, you can try upping the master out in HS 2XL like I stated above. I know when I do an export I always leave a little headroom as I do intend to master the final 2 track mix.

But if I am just exporting to burn a quick mix to CD for checking on another system I dont seem to have much trouble getting the mix out at about -3dB which should be more then enough for normal listening.

I dont know what wave editors you have tried but unless I mess about with the audio the mix is identical to what I get out of the direct export from Sonar when I am finished maximizing it.

What you also might not be taking into account is how you are monitering your mix output from HS 2XL. You can turn up the volume and it sounds splendid coming out of your speakers, but is it really the exact level of the mix. The only way to really tell the exact level of the mix is by lookiing at the final 2 track wave file, either in HS 2XL or in a dedicated wave editor. If your waves look small and dont peak out at -3dB or so, then it is not HS 2XL's fault at all for not maximizing the final output. You have to control that from the application, not the speakers you are listening through.

I guess I would stick with my suggestion above and try boosting the main output of HS 2XL only for the final export. Try it and let me know how that works. I cant think of anything else that you could be doing that would effect it.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 27, 2006 02:30 pm

Well first of all, I do not turn up my speakers to achieve a louder mix. My monitors stay at a lower level from which all my cds will sound good and my mix can actually compete in the software at the same level. But I actually have been wondering where the hell the master volume is in HS 2XL so if you could tell me where it is or if you have an idea then that would be great. Also, I was told not to normalize each individual track but only the overall mix, is this a good approach?
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Mar 27, 2006 11:12 pm

I'll go for the normalizing thing first. There is a yes and no answer to that. If your tracks are all pretty even, or at the same level. Then the answer is no, you dont need to normalize them as individual tracks. That would only be needed if you had a track that was weak or low, level wise.

For the overall mix, or final 2 track mix. Yes, normalizing is somewhat like doing a maximizing with DSP. It does not use compression or anything like that. It simply raises the overall volume with the loudest parts or peaks topping off at whatever you set the ceiling at. In some applications however it can be set to go past the clipping point.

So yes, to get the mix to its loudest that is one good simple option.

For my statement about the speaker volume, I should explain that a little better.

Your mix sounds fine and at a good level, because you speakers are set to playback that mix at a set level. However, the final stereo mixdown wave may not be at that perfect level that you hear there. It seldom works out that way. That is the nature of digital, it keeps itself in check so as not to go into digital clipping. It should export fairly close to what you are hearing, but is usually a bit lower then what your mix coming direct out is at.

What program are you buring the CD with if I may aks? This might help a little.

As for the master volume. It should be available near the bottom of your track view, unless it is dissabled in the view options. As well it should appear to the far right in your mixer view. I have used nothing but Pro Audio and Sonar for years, and never messed about too much with HS so I cant honestly tell you what it will look like. That version is a few years old now so I cant even locate a good description of it to try and find a screen shot.

If you could do one thing for though, and this will help solve and explain some of what might be goin on. Export a file you feel is playing at a the volume you want in HS and save it as a .wav file. Then open it either back into HS as just the stereo file, or open it in a wave editor and let me know how high the loudest peaks are on the scale. As in -6dB or -3dB or what ever. The scale should be on the left of the wave editor view in HS or even in most editor applications. I am guessing you exported wave file is going to be maxing out around -6dB to -12dB.

Most modern CD's today, especially the heavy music is so over compressed and over maximized it has the life litterally squeezed out of it. So if you are comparing your mix to something of the modern day era. It is sad to say that the only way to achieve that kind of percieved loudness is to maximize the hell out of it.

I cant tell you how many CD's I have done for metal guys who tell me it isnt as loud as whoever. So I make them a copy of their CD crushed to oblivion like they think it should be. Then they wonder why there is no life left in the mix. Then I play the original CD for them. Not really that much quieter, but wait a minute, it has its life back again. Then I have to explain how that happens.

Hope this helps a little. If not let me know what else I can explain.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 29, 2006 11:14 pm

Well noize, I found the master volume which was a small button at the bottom which really looks like nothing but ended up being something important. By boosting that up, I can get songs with only a few tracks to sound fairly loud after export but I have just made a song with around 10 tracks including heavy drums and all sorts of frequencies. In order to save it from clipping, I must level out all of the tracks and I am still left with a just bearable loudness level in the program but then it goes down after export. There are very thin peaks which reach the limit so i can't really raise the level without compression or the like.

basically I am getting into all sorts of methods to raise the level but my problem is still the same. In the program it is loud and clear but then upon export it is much quieter and I think the mix may sound a bit muddled but it may just be because its quiet. I am not burning to CD from the program. I am comparing by exporting the songs and playing them in my MUSICMATCH media player.

...soo its not a matter of me being some metal head wanting piercing levels. I just want my mix to come out the way I hear it the entire time I am working on it in my software...
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Mar 29, 2006 11:55 pm

I hope you didnt think I was relating it directly to you on the metal head thing. It honestly was only for the purpose of relaying the way the current trend has been for pressing CD's these days.

Are you exporting to a .wav file at 16 bit 44.1 kHz? Or are you exporting to mp3 to play it in MusicMatch?

That might be part of the problem there. Not saying it is, but it very well could be. I dont know how well MusicMatch handles a wave or mp3 for that matter. I personally only trust 2 players, Windows Media Player and WinAmp. There are several others as well but those seem to work the best for me.

I am wondering if it is a level matching differance. The only way to set them to match what is coming out of HS is to make a perfect match levels wise with your meters for your sound card. For this you will need to have an exact copy of the same track, preferably a consumer type CD. Load it into HS and see were the meters go to. Then do the same with your player and see if they match. I would be willing to bet the player bounces the meters below what HS does.

I'll keep watching this thread and try and get ya through to the end of this.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Mar 30, 2006 12:42 am

lol, don't worry I didn't think you meant me. If I sounded a little peeved it was only because I want to stop having problems!

I am exporting to .wav at 16 bit 44.1 khz. which music match will play.

hmmm, I'm kind of following your last paragraph, are you basically saying that between HS and a CD, the level will be consistant but the media player will most likely be an inaccurate representation? Hopefully I will have time tommorow to try your test. I tried comparing musicmatch to windows media player but the volume meters kind of vary and I'm not sure that you can really do a fair test.

Thank you for your commitment to my problem. I will burn to a cd and see how that works out.
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Mar 30, 2006 10:16 pm

No, I didnt think you were peaved at all. I figured I had better make the statment though in case someone else reading may get that impresion that I was being a bit of a puttz.

OK, the 16/44.1 wav is the best bet for making the direct comparison. IT will give the most accurate representation of the recording.

AS for the differances in the players. I think the variation in level may just be between HS and the players themselves. I know there is even a differance in the output level between WinAMp and MediaPlayer themselves. Once I set my levels to match as I stated above, I never touch them again.

What happens is HS has its own level set internally. And MusicMatch, Win MedaiPlayer and all the rest have their settings on the app itself, but they are also subject to the Windows Sound Control panel. So this is were the differance can be happening. I am not saying it is an absolute thing, but odds are good that is were the differance in the volume is happening.

I guess I should ask as well if you are using the Mobile Pre for both HS and the MusicMAtch player. Or are you using the Mobile Pre for HS and a stock card for the Player? If that is the case that as well can cause a differance in volume.

But if you are using the Mobile Pre for both. When you make the comparison to set the level to match, use the meters in the Mobile Pre's control panel and you will get the most accurate settings.

And hey, no problem following it through. That is what we are here for. The community works well that way. Your input helps others, and so it goes. They help someone else and so on.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Apr 01, 2006 08:47 pm

Well Noize, I think a way to look at it is to visualize my CW as a media player. My musicmatch and windows player both have different volume capacities within themselves regardless of the overall output level of my mobil-pre. So I think the CW just has a very high volume output and then mixes down to a more nuetral file that isnt so hot.

Looking back, a few songs I have that are maybe 4 tracks maximum playing at the same time, are certainly loud enough coming out. But I just made a song with many tracks and this brings me to a dilema. The song must export much quieter in order to fit in all of these tracks without clipping. I recorded all of the tracks at around -6db and lowered some from there afterwards. I also lowered some volume levels a bit and then raised the master to about 4db which was the max it could really go before losing quality. But in the end the song came out at about half the output level that another 4 track song came out with.

How should I go about fixing this?
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Apr 02, 2006 04:58 pm

I am beggining to think that HS does as you stated limit the output a bit then to prevent distortion. I know in Sonar I have alwasy been able to export a hot enough track to go test without using Wavelab to maximize. But I usually in the end do run it into a 2 track editor to do the final run to get it to max level.

I wonder if you were to export it to the 2 track mix, then open a new file in HS and imort that 2 track mix, max its level and then export again a the highest level without distortion. I wonder if that might help avoid the limiting factor if that is what is doing it? I would give that a shot and see what happens.

Otherwise I do believe in our links section there are a couple good audio editors that are in the freeware section that would be able to get your stereo mix maxxed to a final product.

Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Apr 06, 2006 11:00 pm

By bringing the mix down exported file back into HS, I am not able to increase its level any further. It will just clip. So this basically just means mastering it or at least using compression.
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Apr 07, 2006 01:25 pm

I will try and see if I can find someone running the same version as you and have them try as well. Maybe there is something in there I am not seeing. I wish I had it here, it would make it a lot easier to try and pinpoint what is happening in there.
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Apr 07, 2006 02:06 pm

Well to be honest, I really don't follow your logic. When I export a mix at maximum level before clipping and then bring it back into the program, I don't see why I would be able to add volume because the file has the same peaks as its mix did before export. So no program would be able to follow through with this idea. Tell me if I'm misunderstanding your idea.
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Apr 07, 2006 03:07 pm

As I stated above, you really need to look at the final wave form in a dedicated editor that will allow you to see exactly where the file peaks dB wise. I would be willing to bet that when exported from HS the file is going to be as I stated above below the -6dB range. Which means it will be quieter then what you are hearing when you play it back.

What happens with using a dedicated maximizer pluggin is it uses both compression and limiting to get the file to a maximum percieved volume without extending the peaks into clipping range. You need to be carefull though so it doesnt squeeze the life out of the file, meaning the soft and loud parts are still disinguishable.

Does HS have the ability to open a wave file editor?
Goldenmean87
Conjurer of Emotion

Member
Since: Jan 14, 2006
Apr 07, 2006 08:04 pm

Sound forge is the only wave editor I have that has a conventional db scale next to the wave. The file has numerous thin peaks that exceed -6db. This is pretty much visually obvious because the lines reach right up to the line so its not a guessing game really.

Anyway, it is basically exporting as loud as it can go but its still lamely quiet. This of coarse is when there are many tracks to squeeze in...when I have only a few tracks, I am able to get a louder song in the end.
Noize2u
HRC Pro Member
OVERKILL

Administrator
Since: Apr 04, 2002
Apr 07, 2006 09:11 pm

Man, this is going to drive me nuts untill I figure out why it is doing that. I may just for yucks when I get a little time try and build a couple of differant files in an older version of Cakewalk Pro Audio or the first version of Sonar and see if I can duplicate what is happening to you.

I've been using their stuff since the very first application they made and I just dont remember ever seeing this issue before. But then again, I have not honestly used HS in any version that I can recall. So like you stated earlier it may be only related to HS.

I am honestly baffled here by this.

Home > Community > Mixing Forum > Output and Mixdown Discrepancy - Mixing Forum

If you would like to participate in the forum discussions, feel free to register for your free membership.


Del.icio.us Reddit Digg It StumbleUpon

[ Home ] [ Search HRC ] [ Help Support HRC ] [ Contact Us ] [ Advertise on HRC ] [ Privacy Policy ]

Home Recording Connection is hosted on HostPC servers, the best web hosting available.
Reproduction of original content within this site without permission is prohibited. All content copyright ©2007 Home Recording Connection.
Home Recording Connection is owned and operated by dB Masters Multimedia Inc.. All rights reserved.

HRC Sponsors: Tickets
Sex Pistols Tickets
Lyrics
Become a Sponsor > > >



Processing Request.
Have Patience, Don't Keep Clickin'